What you get with new
The Building Act's ten year implied warranties, a defects period, and a home that meets the current Building Code for insulation, glazing and ventilation. A new build is exempt from the Reserve Bank's loan to value restrictions, so the deposit can be smaller. Running costs are usually lower and less should need replacing in the early years. On a terraced townhouse you also get a modern layout, a garage and a small, easy section.
What you give up
You wait for it to be built, and the date can move. You buy from plans, so you need to read them. Sections are smaller and the homes are closer together. The street is new, so the trees are young. And some buyers simply prefer the feel of an older house.
What you get with existing
You see it, you can move in on settlement day, and you can often buy a larger section. Prices for an older home of the same size can be lower, because the building is older.
What you take on
Maintenance and surprises. A builder's report before you buy, then a roof, a kitchen, insulation or rewiring within a few years on some homes built last century. Often higher power bills. Limited warranties: the vendor warranties in the sale agreement, plus whatever is left of the Building Act's ten year cover if the home was built or altered recently. A larger deposit under the lending rules.
How to compare
Compare the total cost over five years, not the price. Add the likely maintenance and the heating bill on the older home. Add the time waiting on the new one. Then ask which home you want to live in. Our pages for home buyers and investors go into more detail for each.
Sources
- MBIE Building Performance: Implied warranties and defects
- New Zealand Legislation: Building Act 2004
- Reserve Bank of New Zealand: Reserve Bank to ease LVR restrictions (October 2025)
- MBIE Building CodeHub: Decision on the H1 energy efficiency transition period
Checked October 2026. General information only, not legal, tax or financial advice.